strange Yaw saturation
Posted: Fri May 10, 2013 1:44 pmHi,
after doing a lot of dry testing, I went out for the first maiden flight of my Y6 with AQ (used MK on the
same frame before).
Flying was nearly impossible: normal reaction of the copter to nick and roll command, but no reaction
to yaw commands at all (and no controller reaction while turning the craft by hand)?!?
I did this together with a college of mine (controller specialist
), but we had no success in controlling yaw
(either by controller setup or yaw stick commands). After trying for nearly 3 hours we gave up.
Back at home, I'm trying to analyze the problem.
What I found out so far:
After lowering the Throttle Scale factor from 0.7 to 0.3, the copter reacts to yaw stick movements
(I do the testing with all props removed).
So I set Tilt Rate PID and Tilt Angle PID all to zero to elliminate any influence and put the Yaw Rate PID
and Yaw Angle PID to the default values.
When I start the motors, the copter reacts to yaw stick movements. But with time passing by, there seems to be
a bigger reaction time between sticks change and motors changing speed. After some time, there is no reaction to yaw stick movements any more. If I start rotating the copter in yaw axis, I notice the yaw controller is still active (motors change speed as direct reaction to the rotation).
I will post the log file of my testing.
From 0 - 2000 the motors react to yaw stick movement.
At about 3300 there seems to be a saturation effect (at -180, which is my Yaw Rate OM?!?) and there
is no reaction to the stick movement at about 4050. At about 5500 I rotated the copter by hand and had a controller
reaction, but still no stick reaction at about 6700.
Some informations about my copter:
Y6 with SimonK ESCs,
AHM 36-6 motors with 12x4.5 CFK props.
4s 2450 mAh battery
Mixing: Hexa coax default in GCS 1.2.1
After stopping the motors and starting again, it is the same as before: reaction to stick movements for
some time, after that: no reaction any more. There seems to be a windup effect which is resetted by stopping
the motors.
Any help would be appreciated...
Daniel
P.S. Is there some kind of diagram of the control loops (my controller specialist college is asking me this all the time
)?
This my be helpful to find out where the saturation is happening.
after doing a lot of dry testing, I went out for the first maiden flight of my Y6 with AQ (used MK on the
same frame before).
Flying was nearly impossible: normal reaction of the copter to nick and roll command, but no reaction
to yaw commands at all (and no controller reaction while turning the craft by hand)?!?
I did this together with a college of mine (controller specialist
), but we had no success in controlling yaw(either by controller setup or yaw stick commands). After trying for nearly 3 hours we gave up.
Back at home, I'm trying to analyze the problem.
What I found out so far:
After lowering the Throttle Scale factor from 0.7 to 0.3, the copter reacts to yaw stick movements
(I do the testing with all props removed).
So I set Tilt Rate PID and Tilt Angle PID all to zero to elliminate any influence and put the Yaw Rate PID
and Yaw Angle PID to the default values.
When I start the motors, the copter reacts to yaw stick movements. But with time passing by, there seems to be
a bigger reaction time between sticks change and motors changing speed. After some time, there is no reaction to yaw stick movements any more. If I start rotating the copter in yaw axis, I notice the yaw controller is still active (motors change speed as direct reaction to the rotation).
I will post the log file of my testing.
From 0 - 2000 the motors react to yaw stick movement.
At about 3300 there seems to be a saturation effect (at -180, which is my Yaw Rate OM?!?) and there
is no reaction to the stick movement at about 4050. At about 5500 I rotated the copter by hand and had a controller
reaction, but still no stick reaction at about 6700.
Some informations about my copter:
Y6 with SimonK ESCs,
AHM 36-6 motors with 12x4.5 CFK props.
4s 2450 mAh battery
Mixing: Hexa coax default in GCS 1.2.1
After stopping the motors and starting again, it is the same as before: reaction to stick movements for
some time, after that: no reaction any more. There seems to be a windup effect which is resetted by stopping
the motors.
Any help would be appreciated...
Daniel
P.S. Is there some kind of diagram of the control loops (my controller specialist college is asking me this all the time
)?This my be helpful to find out where the saturation is happening.
I'd probably adjust that from my radio first anyway (throws/expo/rates), and only mess with the scaling settings if I can't get what I need from radio adjustments.